I like this headline: Google bows to great firewall of China
So Google’s motto is “Don’t be evil” while, at the same time, it is a multinational corporation ultimately responsible to its shareholders for maintaing a steady rise in profits. Which motivation won out here?
On the one hand I think they weren’t evil here: At least Chinese citizens have access to the Internet’s far-flung resources that Google provides. I truly believe in the transformational power of availability of information and I know for a fact that no matter how good a filter Google puts in place they won’t be able to filter out everything the Chinese government wants them to. Maybe they’re banking on that fact.
On the other hand, Google has to watch out for its bottom line and it’s the shareholders and the Board who determine how evil Google is. Corporations, as a rule, need to profit from their actions as a survival strategy. That is the economic system that we have set up currently.
I would love to see the deliberations from Google at the highest level. What were they talking about? What were the pros and cons from their point of view? Again, could they come out and say, “Yes, we’re filtering content at Google.cn but, don’t worry, we know that we can’t filter 100% of the controversial content so Chinese citizens still have access,” without pissing off the Chinese?